Harvey the Pit Bull Shows Clear Preference for Grandma Over Mom
Why Harvey Listens to Grandma but Not Mom
Harvey, a Pit Bull living in a suburban household, has become the subject of a viral video showing his selective obedience. While his mom repeatedly asks him to get up and go upstairs, Harvey responds with only a long, unimpressed stare. However, when his grandma rises from the couch and begins walking, Harvey immediately follows her without hesitation. The contrast in his behavior has sparked amusement and mild concern among family members.
The video, shared online by Harvey’s mom, captures a moment many pet owners might recognize: a dog who listens selectively based on who is giving the command. Harvey’s mom says she has asked him multiple times to move, but he ignores her until grandma appears. She notes that Harvey’s behavior isn’t aggressive or disobedient in general—he simply seems more motivated to respond to his grandma’s presence. The clip has drawn comments from viewers who relate to similar dynamics in their own homes.
Could Harvey’s Behavior Change Over Time?
Animal behavior experts suggest that dogs often form stronger attachments to certain individuals based on tone, consistency, or past positive reinforcement. In Harvey’s case, it’s possible that grandma uses a calmer voice, offers more treats, or engages in activities he enjoys more frequently. His mom speculates that Harvey may associate her with routines like baths or vet visits, while grandma represents relaxation and affection. This difference in association could explain why Harvey chooses to follow one over the other, even when both give similar commands.
While Harvey’s current preference for grandma is clear, his mom says she’s not taking it personally—yet. She’s started trying new approaches, like using higher-value treats or mimicking grandma’s tone when giving commands. She hopes that with patience and consistency, Harvey will learn to respond to her just as quickly. For now, the video remains a lighthearted reminder that dogs, like people, have their own social preferences and ways of showing loyalty.
Why does Harvey ignore his mom but follow grandma? Harvey likely responds more to grandma due to positive associations, tone of voice, or past experiences that make her presence more motivating for him.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Harvey being disobedient or just selective? Harvey isn’t being disobedient—he’s showing selective obedience, which is common in dogs who bond more strongly with certain individuals based on interaction patterns.
Can Harvey learn to obey his mom as quickly as he does grandma? Yes, with consistent training, positive reinforcement, and matching grandma’s approach, Harvey can improve his responsiveness to his mom over time.